data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d1300/d13003b4bf1f718cb097222c03e6fee1b5dd175a" alt=""
Anyone who has talked to me for ten minutes about cooking knows how I love knives. I like working with them, I like taking care of them, I like the objects themselves. I have a t-shirt with a large chef’s knife on it (pictured). If you have talked to me for twenty minutes about cooking, you probably know how much I hate dull knives, how they make me sad, how I would rather rip things apart with my teeth than use a dull knife (okay, maybe that’s a bit hyperbolic...). If you’ve talked to me for even longer, I have probably shown you the scar on my index finger from when I cut myself because I was using a dull knife and ended up going to the ER to have it stitched up (I finished making dinner first, one-handed, with the bleeding finger held up on top of my head to reduce blood flow. Butternut squash soup, roast chicken I think. Anyway, there wasn’t anyone home to drive me over, so I needed to wait, and what was I going to do, let the soup burn?)
Anthony Bourdain, in
Kitchen Confidential, wrote that there are two things which belong to other people which you never touch when in a kitchen. One is a body part, and the other is a knife. Essentially, according to him, its okay for you to pilfer through someone’s wallet, as long as you don’t touch their knives.
In the US, at least in fine dining, each cook has their own knives for work. You buy them yourself, you take care of them,
you love them, you use them, and when you leave, you take your knives with you. They are your instruments; just like a member of an orchestra will bring their own instrument to rehearsal, cooks bring their knives. And its actually a very apt analogy: knives vary slightly from maker to maker, in shape, weight, size, handle, etc; finding the right knife for you is in many ways like a violinist finding the right instrument for him, with the sound he likes, the response rates, the size, etc. For every stage I’ve done in the US, I’ve brought a chefs knife and a paring knife (which lives in my pocket in a little mini-case).
I asked on my first day when I was changing if I should bring my knives down too. Susanna said that unless I really wanted to, there were knives to be used downstairs. I figured that I would give their knives a try and see how their system works.
It was horrible! The objects with which they cut things hardly have edges, and should probably be called really thin hammers rather than knives. There was only one good knife in the drawer (they store all their knives in a drawer, on top of each other. This means every time you move one knife, you dull every other one in there as it bumps against everything) and I was chopping parsley, which needs a good knife, unless you’re making parsley pesto. So I grabbed this knife and started using it, thanking the kitchen gods that they had at least provided me with one useable instrument.
Five minutes later chef walked in. She set up her station, and then asked “Where’s my knife?” Oops. I rinsed it off and handed it over with chagrin. Apparently she doesn’t mind other people using that knife, as long as she isn’t in need of it herself. She finished her project and handed it back to me. Talk about culture shock!
I think it was day three where I had had enough of these knives. I started to notice that I was altering my chopping technique to use more force so that I could actually work my way through work, and that was scaring me. More force means that if you miss, there’s more likeliness of a trip to the ER. That’s why dull knives are dangerous.
So day three I asked if they had a sharpening stone. Chef laughed. “You like using the stone? What’s wrong with a steel?” Keiji nodded in approval that I would prefer a stone--that’s how the Japanese always do it, and probably part of the whole cultural thing which makes Japanese knives so awesome. They showed me where the stones were hidden, and I pulled them out to start working.
I picked the two main knives that we use in the kitchen for just about everything and started to sharpen them. Or at least try. These are the same knives that I got in my kit for culinary school, and while they are amazing value, the blades are thick and the metal is hard. This means that when sharpening them, especially since they had no edge left to speak of, you need a really rough stone to actually remove scraps of metal from the knife so that you can even create an edge to sharpen. These stones were both super fine. I would love to use them on my knife, but mine is thin and I am very careful to always maintain a good edge on it. Its the same with sandpaper: you can’t smooth down a rough edge on wood with super fine paper, you first use a rough paper to smooth things a little, and then progress to finer and finer grains until you have the polish you want.
Did I improve the knives? Marginally. Was it worth the work? Yes, because I will take every improvement I can manage. Did it do that much? No, not really.
At this point I’m sort of in a catch-22. I can bring my stone in, which is rougher, and have another go at sharpening these things. The question is, will I cause a fuss somehow by bringing in my own stone, saying that theirs aren’t good enough? Or, I can just keep using all their equipment, and be very careful with my fingers. The one thing I can’t do is bring my own knife in. I have two knives out here, but one is identical to all of theirs, meaning that I might not come home with it, and I can’t risk damaging my good knife by bringing it in. Anyone who treats knives that poorly shouldn’t come near my knife, which actually requires care and upkeep. Its the kind of knife which can’t be thrown in a drawer, needs regular washing, and shouldn’t be used for hacking. I’m not totally confident that I could communicate that well enough, and if I can’t get them to treat my knife with the love that I have for it, then they aren’t going to see it.
One more thing that proves how much I love knives? This post.
For more info on knives, you can
read an excerpt from
An Edge in the Kitchen on
egullet.org.
Also, if you have ever been interested in early 20th century pig-butchering, check out this
interactive flash program which was made from an old book.